VMTech
Discuss a project →

eMudhra Withdraws Eight More Intermediate Certificate Authorities

eMudhra Withdraws Eight More Intermediate Certificate Authorities

eMudhra has revoked eight additional intermediate certificate authorities after determining that it could not demonstrate compliant handling of their RSA private keys during a 2025 key-transfer ceremony. The Indian certificate provider had previously described the issuers as unaffected by the incident that led it to revoke eight ECDSA intermediates in October.

The newly revoked group comprises six TLS certificate authorities and two code-signing authorities. eMudhra's certificate list names 195 certificates from them, including 130 issued by EM DV TLS CA - G2C, 63 by EM OV TLS CA - G2C and two by EM OV CS CA - G2C. The company says certificate holders have been moved to replacement certificates.

Same script path, different consequence

The underlying incident dates to a key ceremony on April 30, 2025. eMudhra generated 16 CA keys on Utimaco hardware security modules for intended use in Crypto4A HSMs at its US and EU locations. Because transferring keys between HSMs from different vendors was limited, its PKI operations team wrote a Python script to wrap keys for transport and unwrap them again.

The ceremony included a practice transfer, during which the source HSM's FIPS-approved mode was switched off under an approved exception. After the transfer, the script read private-key material out of the HSM into the ceremony computer's memory and rebuilt keys from that copy.

For eight ECDSA keys, a line in the read-back process truncated the private value to its leading byte. The weak rebuilt keys carried labels almost identical to the original keys and were used for signing and certification. The resulting certificates passed linting and two WebTrust audit cycles, while the weak keys still produced valid signatures.

The eight RSA issuers took the same read-back step, although eMudhra initially concluded that a different code path left them unaffected. The script did not truncate the RSA keys, and signatures continue to validate against their certified public keys. However, private components, including the private exponent and one prime, were present in the memory of the Python process on the ceremony computer.

Compliance evidence could not be established

eMudhra said it could not positively demonstrate that the handling met CPS section 6.2.6, its rule governing the movement of keys into and out of an HSM. Logs and files from the ceremony computer cannot reliably establish how that material was handled. The company reached that conclusion in early November after discussions with browser root programs.

The RSA intermediates were revoked late last week using the cessationOfOperation reason code rather than the keyCompromise code used for the October revocations. Participants in Mozilla's bug discussion have questioned that choice. eMudhra says the wrap-and-unwrap procedure was used only once and that its other key ceremonies generated keys in place. KPMG, hired as an independent reviewer, is due to complete its work by December 4, while eMudhra's inventory of all CA keys is due November 30.

Trust deadlines for certificate holders

eMudhra, which sells certificates under the emSign brand, is leaving the publicly trusted TLS business. It says issuance from its G1 hierarchy will stop before November 16 as remaining customers move to another provider. Microsoft is scheduled to start removing 10 remaining eMudhra roots, including emSign Root CA - G1, from default trust in Windows and Edge on November 16.

Chrome and Firefox will not trust G1 certificates issued after November 16 under eMudhra's phase-out schedule, while Apple will end trust in all G1 certificates on November 30. Organizations using emSign certificates should identify affected chains, deploy and test replacements, and confirm that services remain trusted across their operating systems, browsers and command-line tooling before those deadlines.

#cybersecurity#pkisecurity#certificates#cryptography
Open analytics
On the site 8 views
min read 4 11.11.2026
On Instagram 1 views
Instagram

eMudhra Withdraws Eight More Intermediate Certificate Authorities

Open the post on Instagram ↗