VMTech
Discuss a project →

Italy orders Meta to change Facebook gallery permission settings

Italy orders Meta to change Facebook gallery permission settings

Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta €805 million over a Facebook for Android feature that suggests photos and videos from a user’s phone gallery for posting. The authority found that the feature was enabled by default and accessed photos, videos and related metadata of Italian users without explicit consent.

The case concerns roughly 20 million Android users in Italy. Meta has 60 days to turn the feature off by default, including for people who had already granted gallery access, and to obtain consent through a separate request. Meta told Reuters it intends to appeal and described the sanction as disproportionate.

A single permission was not sufficiently specific

The Garante concluded that Facebook presented gallery access through one device permission covering the app and several functions with different purposes. A general notice about enabling additional functions appeared before the permission request, but it did not clearly tell users that gallery suggestions would also be activated.

When fully granted, such access can allow an app to read a phone’s entire photo archive, typically on an ongoing basis. The authority said that neither users nor the regulator could determine which material was actually used by the feature.

The decision cites Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive in national law. Under that provision, access to information stored on a phone requires free and informed consent because the device forms part of an individual’s private sphere. The authority said the requirement applies regardless of whether data is transmitted elsewhere or harm can be shown.

Deadlines for Meta and scope of the investigation

Within 60 days, Meta must provide a distinct and specific consent flow explaining the purpose of the feature, that it accesses the gallery and how users can disable it. The company must also keep the feature switched off by default for all affected users, including those who had previously granted the broad permission.

Meta must report the work it has begun within 30 days and the measures it has implemented within 90 days. If the company does not meet the 60-day requirement, it may not enable the feature for anyone without valid consent.

The feature has been available since 2023. The investigation began in July 2025 and included the Garante’s own technical analysis. The authority rejected Meta’s position that Ireland’s data protection authority should lead the case, stating that ePrivacy rules do not include a one-stop-shop mechanism.

The Garante said the €805 million penalty represents about 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue. It considered the scale of the affected population, the duration of the breach, a 2019 decision involving the company and what it described as limited cooperation during the investigation. Changes made after the complaint were considered, but the authority judged them late and limited to people who updated the app.

What the ruling means for mobile product teams

The investigation did not assess whether gallery content was used to train AI models; Meta denies such use. The authority may separately examine a newer feature that permits cloud processing of gallery content.

For businesses designing mobile services, the decision makes the operational lesson concrete: permissions for sensitive on-device data should be tied to a clearly stated purpose, optional functionality should not rely on default activation, and consent flows must remain intelligible after a user has granted an operating-system permission.

#dataprivacy#mobileapps#regulation#metapolicy
Open analytics
On the site 0 views
min read 4 15.11.2026
Instagram

Italy orders Meta to change Facebook gallery permission settings

Open the post on Instagram ↗